#90: Inaayat Abdool Satar. email: mr.ias1@yahoo.com - don't criticise any Ulama Do NOT criticise ANY ulama.. Not good, they too are human and err.

"And we have created human weak" (Qur'aan e Kareem)

"All children of Adam(AS) are sinners, but the best of sinners are those who repent" If those Ulama repent, they'll be better than us. Gheebah(back biting) is not permissible. Rather talk to them about these issues face to face.

Sure they will be better than is by far, if they not already. However we discussing this issue from what is apparent. They, these itv ulama, are not only publicly openly halalizing and justifying something absolutly haram but they are also encouraging others to do the same. They deserve to be criticised. If everyone keeps quiet and refrains from speaking out and opposing this evil, it will become accepted as part of islaam. In this case we are not fault finding or looking for ways to disgrace them. They're taking pride and publicly promoting they wrong deeds without any shame, remorse or regret.

What about the quraanic ayat of ''Amr bil ma'roof nahy anil munkar''? Since they refuse to give us a fair hearing face to face, we will take this opportunity to practice this devine command inshaAllah.

At the same time i agree that we should refrain from saying things such as ''they need a bloody good hiding'' etc.

Lastly i promise you that if these very same ulama repent tomorrow and oppose the TV as it ought to, we will kiss their shoes and beg their dua's. The ''hatred'' thats being displayed in this thread is not hatred for them, rather its hatred for they deeds and love for the original true real shariah and islaam.

May ALLAH forgive us all. Ameen

#95: Husain - Re: don't criticise any Ulama

VERY WELL SAID

FEIZAL ALLI

JOHANNESBURG