Hands Off Hartlebury Common

Quoted post


Guest

#714 Re:

2011-07-08 23:42

#713: -

there isn't any benefits to grazing cattle, its already been claimed on here that the council want to turn the place into a wildlife theme park and thats simply not the case. The cattle grazing is being performed for its environmental benefits in ensuring the common is maintained to the standard of the SSSI that it was given. Its common practice on similar heathland habitats, the nearest being the Rifle range and devil's spittlefield between kidderminster and bewdley where they have a rare breed of cattle grazing to maintain the heathland habitat and its working well there

Replies

Steve McCarron

#716 Re: Re:

2011-07-09 01:18:31

#714: - Re:

In which case you would not be planning to put cattle on the site because they will eat the valued flora and fauna which was noted in the earlier two sssi listings and on the new information boards, with reference to the stopping of grazing by WCC for exactly that reason.

Nor would you let cattle graze over a prehistoric archaeological site.

No mention of spraying asulox as a management tool either.

The cattle will not combat the new preponderent plant life, fern, which will always succeed over heather, hence asulox.

Can you tell me the enviromental benefit of creating an artificial, unsustainable 200 acre space that will need tending for ever. Not very carbon neutral.

Can you tell me why 100-150 year old oaks are being cut down in abundance when they were certainaly present at both listings. This one is 22 inches in diameter making it roughley 150 years old

 

http://i1179.photobucket.com/albums/x395/stevemac2/DSCF6638.jpg...

 

Heathland habitats are abundant without grazing and do not rely on it, as heath is plentiful  at hartlebury.

You  are the first person that I have met that thinks your schemes  nearby have been a success. The public I meet have a very different point of view of their own and talk of failing disorganized sites.

 

I would be happy to walk the areas in question with you, with a member of the press, to discuss these points.

 

Steve McCarron